Monday 11 October 2010

The Historian

"A historian is a profit in reverse"

Always a favourite quote of mine and now it seems to be more relevant than ever.

Were we are now
With the spending review just around the corner questions are being raised as to what it will mean for the UK economy.The UK has a national debt of around 950 billion (that's: 950,000,000,000!!), this staggering figure is the problem now facing Chancellor George Osbor
ne but what is he going to do about? This is the question on the mind of many, will raising tuition fees be part of repaying the debt, cancelling child befit is certainly one part of it.
The front line services such as police have already begun making cut backs and other areas of the public sector cringes in the knowledge its almost certain to see heavy job loses.

George Osborne may be cutting back to reduce the budget deficit but what will happen to the Macro economic objectives? Government spending (G) is a key part of Aggregate demand (AD), plotting a reduction in G and thus AD on a Long Run Aggregate Supply (LRAS) has the effect shown bellow:
Output falls from O to O1 and thus GDP falls.. the economy goes into recession! Surely George Osborne knows this? Well a major part of the conservatives plan on keep the economy afloat release a theory called crowed out, as explained in full by a fantastic article written by Joe RS: Joe's Article. Basically the Government expects the private sector to fill in the gap as they deplete the public sector, a valid theory. However this only possible if businesses have money to expand, something which is about to get a whole lot harder if the Monetary Policy Commity decides to raise interest rates!
Has George Osborn factored this into his theory? It certainly raises questions as to how qualified he is to run the economy, lets find out:


The Man in charge
Name:
George Gideon Oliver Osborne
Age: 39
Born: Paddington UK
Degree: Modern History.
Job History:
NHS: recording deaths
Selfridge's: Tidying towels
The Conservative Party
Experience in Economics (including GCSE ):
NONE
Anyone else shiver at the sight of that résumé, Well the city of London for a start! On the positive side every single one of you now reading this probably can say: "I have more experience in economics than the man in charge of the UK economy!" So how did he get the job.. well another Quote springs to mind, this time by Benjamin Franklin exasperated by politics:
"Democracy is two wolves and one lamb voting on what to have for lunch"

Alas more fitted for the present times would be:
"Two politicians and an economist voting on what to do with the economy"
At least there is one good thing, if he studied modern history he should be able to tell us about the 1930s.

The Past
During the period of 1930s the world economy was in a state of depression, in the US this was know as the great depression lasting from 1929 to around 1939 while the UK's problems started in 1918 but were not quite as bad by the late 1939s.
Economic growth was negative, between 1918 and 1921 there was a fall of 25% in output in the UK! The Government debt was large and the government was pressured to lower the deficit, this didn't help the economy!
Many nations were pinned down by something known as the gold standard that fixed their currencies so they could not export effectively.
As a result of the economic depression extremism increased, the Nazi party rose up in Germany and to a lesser extent in the UK, the KKK became stronger in the US and in Italy and Spain far right dictatorships rose up. Eventually Adolph Hitler rose to power in Germany and consumed Europe in war.


The future? (The apocalyptic edition)
World war 1 = war on terror
The Gold standard = The Euro
Economic down turn = Credit crunch
Right extremism = Tea Party Movement, BNP etc..
Government cut back? = Spending review?
World war 3 anyone?

OK so that's the extremest prediction possible (unless we look back the fall of Rome), but there some merit in looking back at the past to judge the future, there are many similarities to then and now and Keynesian models suggest these cut backs will lead to bad times ahead. We have to learn the lessons of the past, lets hope George Osborne did in his history classes. A final quote to consider:
"History repeats itself because no one was listening the first time"

No comments:

Post a Comment